Mad Youth Organise responds to the Milburn Review

Alan Milburn’s review into young people and work has come back with a shocking recommendation: that under 25 year olds should be stripped of the main sickness and disability benefits.

Milburn claims his proposals will set up young people for a ‘decent future’, but it is actually focused on achieving cruel, arbitrary, and unnecessary cuts to the welfare bill that removes the lifelines of many young people. A decent future for us looks like tackling the root causes of mental health crisis: unstable jobs, housing crisis and the climate crisis. 

Milburn’s review recommends that many under 25s can no longer claim PIP or the health element of universal credit. Instead they will be moved onto a new “youth allowance” paid at the basic universal credit rate, even Milburn admits this will leave young, disabled people with less support. Disability doesn’t begin at 25. Removing support for young people is brutal and arbitrary, it will leave thousands of young people without the support they need to survive.

Approximately 1 in 4 young people has a mental health condition. The reason for this awful statistic is the increasingly difficult lives young people are being forced to lead. This is a result of years of economic and social policy making that has focused only on the lobbying demands of corporations. From an unsuitable and traumatising school system, to poverty wages and precarious work, from sky high rents, to climate anxiety, from the systematic shutting of youth services and the absence of any decent mental health care - just existing as a young person is incredibly tough. Let alone as a young, disabled person.

This reality of young people’s lives can’t be wished away by destroying the few forms of support that are available. Forcing sick people into work regardless of whether those jobs are suitable or how ill the person is will cause real harm. Make no mistake, lives will be lost as a result of this policy.

The government is scapegoating young people for being ill, rather than asking the question ‘why are so many young people unwell”? The answers to that question would point to real causes: the corporations that profit from business models that perpetuate the youth mental health crisis, and the neo-liberal austerity policies that strip away support and cause the abysmal absence of adequate mental health care.

Once again the government is reducing young people’s worth down to whether or not they are economically active. Time and again mentally ill people have had their recovery measured only by their ability to sell their labour.  As young people who have experienced severe mental illness we reject these individualistic ideas of illness and wellness, rooted in the concept that our lives only have meaning if we are economically productive - rather than looking at our wellbeing, our happiness and our own ideas of what ‘recovery’ or ‘ a decent life’ really means.

Giving young people the ability to live happier, calmer, gentler lives is the first step in enabling more of us to thrive, and in thriving to be able to participate more fully in the communities and society we are part of.

Burnham’s government is choosing to attack young people at a time when our lives are already impossible.  Burnham came to power promising something different, an end to the neoliberal policies which have inflicted such harm on this country. It is those very policies which are driving the youth mental health crisis. Instead of cuts Burnham should be planning action to curb the power of corporations and increase funding for youth services, these are the types of actions which can end the youth mental health crisis. No young person, or anyone who cares about young people can support Burnham’s government while they are driving through such cruel attacks.

What young people need is support, security and the freedom to live fulfilling lives on their own terms, not further cuts and punishment. We will fight for an end to age-based restrictions on disability benefits, properly funded mental health services and for the root causes of the mental health crisis to be addressed. We demand the right to define recovery and a decent life for ourselves, beyond the narrow measure of economic productivity.

Last year the disabled community came together to stop the government’s planned welfare cuts. Once again we will collectively fight the government's cuts and cruel demonisation of young, disabled people. Regardless of age or disability an attack on one of us is an attack on all of us.

Hope Worsdale